Tracing 81 quatrains attributed to Rumi in previous sources

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Professor of Persian language and literature, Azarbaijan Shahid Madani University, Tabriz , Iran

2 Ph.D. Persian language and literature - mystical literature,Azarbaijan Shahid Madni University, Tabriz-Iran

Abstract

 
Based on the conducted research and also the views of researchers in the field of Persian quatrains, it has been confirmed that many quatrains from ancient sources have found their way among the quatrains attributed to mystic poets, including the quatrains attributed to Rumi. It is clear that doing any kind of research on the quatrains of each of the poets, before identifying the common quatrains, may lead to wrong results; As most of the researches done about Rumi's quatrains, due to the common quatrains that definitely exist in them, they are not of scientific validity.Therefore, following the previous research in tracing the quatrains of others in the quatrains attributed to Rumi, In this research, by examining the manuscripts and printed sources, we have also found other involved quatrains among Divan-e Kabir's quatrains, which belong to previous poets. Among these poets, Ohaddin Kermani, Attar Neishabouri and Afzaldin Kashani have the most number of Common quatrains in Divan-e Kabir.
Keywords: Divan-e Kabir, common quatrains, previous poets, previous sources, manuscripts.
Introduction:
Undoubtedly, one of the most important and fundamental topics in the field of literary criticism is the issue of correctness of attribution; Because before determining the correctness of attribution in each part of a literary work, any kind of research about it will be useless and will not have scientific validity. A critic must know how innovative the work he discusses and researches; And if in that work something from the works and books of others has been quoted in different forms, what are those works?
Materials & Methods:
More and more detailed investigations in the manuscripts and printed versions of divans of poets and earlier prose texts as well as poetry collections show that there are many common quatrains among these works, especially in the poet mystics works. There are, among the most important of them, we can point to the quatrains attributed to Rumi in Divan-e-Kabir, edited by Badi-ul-ZamanFaruzanfar. The eighth volume of this Divan contains 1983 quatrains. from the works and writings of Rumi, it can be seen that he was well acquainted with the literary works and especially the mystical works before him and was influenced by them in creating his works. he recited the poems and especially the quatrains of his predecessors in sermons, but his disciples recorded these poems and quatrains in his name. The uncertainty of the attribution of all the quatrains mentioned in Divan-e-Kabir is a point that most researchers in this field have pointed out.
The truth of the matter is that evaluating and criticizing the attributions of quatrains in Divan-e-Kabir requires opening and exploring new and wide paths that for some reasons cannot be imagined as an end; Because compiling the history of Persian quatrains and reviewing them, first of all, it is necessary to have reliable texts, while a large amount of the heritage of Persian quatrains has remained untouched in the treasure of manuscripts in the libraries of Iran and the world. Sources that without examining them, any research done in this field will definitely be incomplete. but by accepting this principle that there is no final word in the field of research and research, one can start a long and wide path and with more research, add to previous achievements and pave the way for future research. In the current research, in order to find the common quatrains of Divan-e-Kabir and other poets' quatrains, in addition to examining their printed Divans, even if possible, several manuscripts of these diVans have also been cited. in addition to divans, previous prose texts and numerous poetry collections were also examined in order to obtain more accurate and reliable results. in this research.
Discussion & Result:
By examining the research done about Rumi's quatrains, we often come to theses and articles in which quatrains from Divan-e-Kabir are mentioned, which do not originally belong to Rumi, in many cases even these quatrains are the main focus of these studies. perhaps one of the main reasons for the scholars' reference to this kind of quatrains is their rhetorical highlights and literary beauty, which attracts the researchers' attention at the very first glance; Therefore, sometimes we see that in some of these articles, most of the references are related to quatrains that belong to previous poets! Therefore, it can be said that the results of such researches about Rumi's quatrains are definitely not scientific and referable.
Undoubtedly, every reader with a good taste, with a curious look at Rumi's quatrains, without checking the previous Persian quatrains, will doubt in attributing some of them to Rumi, and it is possible that such quatrains must belong to another poet; the reason why we are faced with such quatrains in Divan-e-Kabir of Rumi is that most of the mystics in their statements and even in their writings have not been satisfied with Sufi sayings and poems to express their meaning, Rather, they have also paid attention to previous non-Sufi literary works, and have used them to express their high mystical meanings. This point caused the sayings and works of prominent mystics to be mixed with poems and especially quatrains of other Sufi and non-Sufi poets, and some of the literary works of others were wrongly attributed to this category of mystics. Therefore, the more familiar this group of mystics became with poems and quatrains and in general previous literary works, the level of mixing other people's poems with their poems increased. due to the fact that Rumi had memorized in his mind a lot of Persian and even Arabic literary works of his predecessors, Therefore, it is natural that he recited quatrains of previous poets, and his disciples also recorded those quatrains in his name.
Conclusion:
 by examining the previous works, 81 quatrains from Divan-e-Kabir, which belonged to twenty-one poets were determined. Among them, Ohad al-ddin Kermani with 41 quatrains, Attar Neishabouri with 14 quatrains and Afzal ul-ddin Kashani with 4 quatrains have the highest number of quatrains.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Ebrahim Rahimi Zanganeh, Soheila Yari Guldara and Leila Rahmatian (2016), "Recognition of the source of 38 quatrains attributed to Rumi in literary and historical texts", Two Quarterly Journal of Literature, No. 3. [in Persian]
Akhsikti, Athir ul-ddin (1958), Divan, edited by Ruknuddin Homayoun Farrokh, Tehran: Rudaki bookstore. [in Persian]
Esfahani, Kamal ul-ddin Ismail (2019), Divan Ghazalyat and Rubaiyat, edited and researched by Dr. Mohammad Reza Zia, Tehran: Dr. Mahmoud Afshar Endowment Foundation. [in Persian]
Esfahani, Mahmoud bin Mohammad (1985), Dostur al-wezarat, by the efforts of Dr. Reza Anzabi-nejad, Tehran: Amir Kabir. [in Persian]
Anvari Abivardi, Ohad al-ddin (1987), Divan, by Saeed Nafisi, Tehran: Sekke-Pirouz. [in Persian]
Ohad al-ddin Kermani (1987), Divan Rabaiyat, edited by Ahmad Abu Mahboob and introduced by Mohammad Ebrahim Bastani Parizi, Tehran: Soroush. [in Persian]
Baba Afzal Kashani (1932), Rubaiyat, by Saeed Nafisi, Tehran: Faculty Library. [in Persian]
Baba Afzal Kashani (1972), Divan. By Mustafa Faizi, Hassan Atefi, Abbas Bahnia and Ali Sharif, Kashan: Kashan Department of Culture and Art. [in Persian]
Beheshti, Ahmad (1977), Rubai Nameh, Tehran: Rosane Publications. [in Persian]
Taj al-ddin Ahmad Wazir (1974), Bayaz Tajuddin Ahmad Wazir, under the supervision of Iraj Afshar and Mortaza Taymuri, Isfahan: University of Isfahan. [in Persian]
Jam Namghi, Sheikh Ahmad (1998), Divan, by the efforts of Ahmad Karmi, Khaje Publishing Company. [in Persian]
Joveyni, Atta Malik bin Muhammad bin Muhammad (2012), Tarikh Jahangashai Joveyni, Vol. 2, corrections and annotations by Dr. Habibullah Abbasi and Dr. Iraj Mehraki, second edition, Tehran: Zovar. [in Persian]
Joveyni, Atta Malik bin Muhammad bin Muhammad (2006), the history of the world of Joveyni. Volume 1, introduction, correction and notes by Habibullah Abbasi and Iraj Mehraki, Tehran: Zovar. [in Persian]
Razi, Najmuddin (1389), Mursad al-Abad, under the care of Dr. Mohammad Amin Riahi, Tehran: Scientific and Cultural. [in Persian]
Rahman M0shtaqmehr, Yadollah Nasrollahi and Mahnaz Nezami (1400), "New sources of 75 quatrains from Rumi's Great Diwan based on Nozha Majales", two chapters of scientific research journal, Ancient Persian Literature, No 1. [in Persian]
Zarinkoob, Abd ul- Hossein (1982), Literary Criticism (Volume 1), Tehran: Amir Kabir. [in Persian]
Saad Salman, Masoud (1988), Divan, vol.2, edited by Dr. Mahdi Noorian, Isfahan: Kamal. [in Persian]
Soad Sawari, Mohammadreza Salehi and Parveen Golizadeh (2015), "Artistic and visual effects in Rumi's quatrains", Poetry Research Magazine (Bostan Adab), No. 30. [in Persian]
Seyed Ali Mirafazli (2000), "Ohad al-ddin Kermani's Rubaiyat in the oldest sources", Ma'arif, no. 17. [in Persian]
Seyed Ali Mirafazli (1376), "Morwarid Kermani and Wandering Quatrains", Maarif Magazine, Vol. 3. [in Persian]
Seifi Neishabouri, Ali bin Ahmad (2019), Rasail al-Ashaq and Wasal al-Mushtaq, by Javad Bushra, Tehran: Dr. Mahmoud Afshar Historical and Literary Publications Group. [in Persian]
Shamisa, Cyrus. (1374). Sīr Rābī in Persian poetry. Tehran: Ferdous. [in Persian]
Shahin Haghighi (2017), "Topics, Rituals and Popular Beliefs in Maulavi's Quatrains ", Journal of Popular Culture and Literature, No. 24. [in Persian]
Atar Neishabouri, Fariduddin (1979), Mukhtarnameh, with introduction and correction by Mohammad Reza Shafiei Kadkani, Tehran: Tos. [in Persian]
Awfi, Muhammad (1945), Labab al-albab, edited by Edward Brown, Leiden: Brill. [in Persian]
Aufy, Muhammad (1980), Jameem-al-Hakeyat and Lavamae al-Rayayat. (Chapter 14 of the first part), edited by Dr. Amir Bano Musfa (Kirimi), Tehran: Farhang Iran Foundation. [in Persian]
Ain al-Qozat Hamdani (1998), Tamhidat, by Afif Asiran, Tehran: Manochehri Library. [in Persian]
Ghaznavi, Seyyed Hasan (1983), Divan, revised and introduced by Mohammad Taghi Modares Razavi, Tehran: Asatir. [in Persian]
Farrokhi Sistani (2006), Divan, corrected by Mohammad Dabir Siyaghi, Tehran: Zovar. [in Persian]
Quchani, Abdullah (1992), Persian poems of Takht Suleiman tiles, Tehran: University Publishing Center. [in Persian]
Qonavi, Sadr al-ddin (1985), Tabserat al-Mubtadi and Tazkerat al-Montahi. edited by Najafaqoli Habibi, Maarif magazine. [in Persian]
Karachi, Roohangiz (2017), The history of women's poetry from the beginning to the 8th century. Tehran: Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies. [in Persian]
Mojir al-ddin Bilqani (1979), Divan, edited by Dr. Mohammad Abadi, Tabriz: Institute of History and Culture of Iran. [in Persian]
Mohammad Amir Mashhadi, Abdullah Watheq Abbasi, Mohammad Reza Mashhadi (2010), "Intellectual Stylistics of Rumi's Rubaiyat" Persian Poetry and Prose Quarterly, No. 9. [in Persian]
Moradi, Arham and Mohammad Afshin Vafaei (2015), The Ancient Ship of Rabaiyat. Tehran Sokhan. [in Persian]
Mahnaz Nizami, Rahman Moshtaqmehr and Yadollah Nasrollahi (2019) "Tracing 35 quatrains attributed to Rumi in manuscripts and Divan Sana'i and older texts", Research Journal of Persian Language and Iranian Dialects, Vol. 10. [in Persian]
Monshi, Nasrollah (2001), translation of Kalila and Damneh, corrected and explained by Mojtaba Minavi, Tehran: University of Tehran. [in Persian]
Maulvi, Jalal ul-ddin Mohammad Balkhi (1984), Kollyat Shams or Divan-e Kabir, vol.8, with corrections and margins by Badi ul-Zaman Forozanfar, Tehran: University of Tehran. [in Persian]
Mirafazli, Seyyed Ali (2014), War of Quatrains: Recovery and Correction of Ancient Persian Quatrains, Tehran: Sokhan. [in Persian]
Nasafi, Aziz ul-ddin (1980), Kashf al-Haqayq, by the efforts of Dr. Ahmad Mahdavi Damghani, Tehran: Book Translation and Publishing Company. [in Persian]
Yaghmor, Mohammad (2016), Safina-e Tarmad, with the efforts of Omid Sarvari and the collaboration of Seyyed Baqer Abtahi, Tehran: Literary and Historical Publications of Dr. Mahmoud Afshar's endowments.
Manuscripts:
Abul Majid Tabrizi, Muhammad bin Masoud, (721 AH-723 AH), Safina Tabriz, copy number 14590, Majlis Library. [in Persian]
Qonavi, Sadr al-Din, (written: 660 A.H.), Tabserat al-Mubtadi and Tazkerat al-Muntahi, No. 557/3, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Abu Mansour Ismail bin Abd al-Moman Isfahani, (written in 736 AH), translation of Awarif al-Maarif Suhrvardi, number 4595, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Afzaluddin Kashani, (Ninth Century Library), Microfilm Quatrains. No. 238/4, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Anvari Abivardi, Hassan, (708 AH), Divan, Microfilm No. 51F, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Ohad al-ddin Kermani, (706 AH), Quatrains, No. 1422 F, Hagia Sophia Library, Turkey, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Termazi, Seyyed Burhan ul-ddin Mohagheg (written in 687 AH), Maarif, No. 6118, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Collection of poems, copy number 900, (late 7th century or early 8th century) Majlis Library. [in Persian]
Joveyni, Mahmoud bin Ahmad, (written: 660 AH), Manahaj Sefiyeh, No. 1/557 F, Central Library of Tehran University. [in Persian]
Khaqani, (writings of the late 6th century), Divan, copy number 976, Majlis Library. [in Persian]
Siraj Tabrizi, Mahmoud ibn Ahmad (written in 730 AH), a collection of Persian poems, copy number 2051 of Aya Sufiya Library, number 108F, in the handwriting of Mahmoud ibn Ahmad Siraj Tabrizi, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
A collection of poems, (eighth century), number 564 F (Halat Effendi, 238, Sulaymaniyah Library), Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Seyyed Hasan Ghaznavi, (probably 11th century), Divan, copy number 2/7886, Majlis Library. [in Persian]
Abd ul- Aziz Kashani, (Eighth Century Library) collection of poems by Ruzat al-Nazar and Nozha al-Khater, copy number 766 of Istanbul library, number 247 f, central library of Tehran University. [in Persian]
Attar Neishabouri, Farid al-ddin, (written in 731 AH), Mukhtarnameh, number 2/1380 F, author name: Abu Bakr bin Ali bin Mohammad Esfraini known as Bakan, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Qonavi, Sadr al-ddin, (663 AH), copy 328 f, articles, Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Kamal al-ddin Ismail, (written in 725 A.H.), copy number 1049, Majlis library. [in Persian]
Mujir al-ddin Bilaqani, (probably the 8th century) Divan, No. 170F- Tehran University Central Library. [in Persian]
Classical Persian Literature

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 09 February 2024

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics